What Has Evidence-Based Investing Done For Me Lately?

Evidence-Based Investment Insights: What Has Evidence-Based Investing Done for Me Lately?

In our last piece, “Factors That Figure in Your Evidence-Based Portfolio,” we introduced three key stock market factors (equity, value and small-cap) plus two more for bonds: term and credit. Combined, these factors have long played an important role in many evidence-based investment approaches.

Does this mean we have everything we need to know to build better and better portfolios? Hardly.

The Benefits Of Evolving Evidence

Continued research has helped identify additional market factors and potential sources of expected return. Three of the more prominent include investment, profitability and momentum.

  • The investment factor: Companies that invest more conservatively have historically been associated with higher average returns than companies investing more aggressively, all else equal. More recent research also reinforces that investment and profitability can interact, reminding us that no factor should necessarily be viewed in isolation.
  • The profitability factor: Companies with relatively strong profitability have historically been associated with higher average returns than companies with weaker profitability, although the premium does not appear consistently in every period.
  • The momentum factor: Stocks with relatively strong recent performance have historically tended to continue outperforming stocks with weaker recent performance over shorter horizons. Momentum can also reverse, and implementation costs are an important consideration.

Ongoing analysis has also helped researchers and practitioners refine how new and existing factors interact.

For example, Dimensional’s updated research on the evolution of small-cap investing describes how momentum, profitability and investment considerations can influence the implementation of small-cap strategies. Rather than treating any single characteristic as a stand-alone answer, the objective is to evaluate how multiple sources of information may work together while considering diversification, trading costs and practical implementation.

This is an important reminder of what evidence-based investing is meant to be: not a fixed set of rules, but a process that continues to evaluate new information as research evolves.

Factoring For Alternatives

Beyond traditional stock and bond investments, another area of ongoing research involves alternative investments and the different sources of risk and return they may introduce.

Certain alternative assets and strategies (including private credit, real assets, real estate and other specialized investments) may offer return patterns that differ from traditional public stocks and bonds. In some circumstances, those differences may contribute to portfolio diversification.

But “alternative” is an extremely broad category, and diversification benefits should never be assumed. Alternative investments can introduce additional considerations, including limited liquidity, higher expenses, valuation uncertainty, greater manager dependence and longer investment horizons.

Whether any alternative investment belongs in a portfolio depends on the investor’s individual circumstances, objectives, liquidity needs, time horizon, tolerance for risk and the characteristics of the investment itself.

Sustainable Investing

Some investors also want their investment portfolios to reflect environmental, social or other personal priorities.

Evidence-based analysis can be useful here as well. Environmental, social and governance considerations may provide additional information about potential risks and opportunities associated with a company or investment. At the same time, incorporating sustainability preferences does not inherently guarantee stronger investment returns.

An evidence-based approach can help investors distinguish between their personal values, financially material considerations and claims about investment performance, while evaluating the potential tradeoffs involved.

The Big Picture On Evidence-Based Investing

We acknowledge that we have just thrown a lot of information at you in a compact space. Here are five principles to consider when evaluating new and existing investment factors:

  • Take your time. A newly identified factor may look compelling in historical data, but that alone does not establish that it will persist. Favor ideas supported by a sensible economic rationale, meaningful evidence across different markets and time periods, and continued scrutiny.
  • Consider the costs. Even if a factor appears to exist in theory, that does not necessarily mean it can be captured effectively in a real-world portfolio. Trading costs, taxes, fund expenses and other implementation considerations matter.
  • Understand how factors interact. Factors do not necessarily operate independently. Improving exposure to one may alter exposure to another, and newer research continues to explore how those relationships affect expected returns.
  • Identify your priorities. Investment decisions should reflect your individual goals, risk tolerance, time horizon and, when relevant, personal values. Evidence can help inform those decisions, but it does not eliminate the need for individual judgment.
  • Do not forget to diversify. As we covered in earlier Evidence-Based Investment Insights, concentrating too heavily in any one factor can create additional risk. Factor exposure should be considered within the context of a broadly diversified portfolio appropriate for the investor’s circumstances.

How We Can Help

Opinions can vary considerably on whether, when and how particular factors or investment strategies should play a role in portfolio construction. This is where a disciplined, evidence-based advisory process can provide useful perspective.

New investment ideas can attract attention quickly, particularly when accompanied by compelling recent performance. Before incorporating them into a long-term investment strategy, it can be useful to ask:

  • Have the results appeared across different markets and time periods?
  • Is there a credible economic rationale for why the relationship may persist?
  • Have the findings been replicated or challenged by independent researchers?
  • Do the potential benefits remain after considering costs, taxes and implementation?
  • How would the investment affect the risks and diversification of the overall portfolio?

All of this takes time. Yet one need only glance at daily headlines to become awash in ideas from competing and often conflicting voices. Being informed can be helpful; constantly reacting to new information can make it more difficult to maintain a patient, disciplined investment process.

We welcome conversations about evolving investment research and how particular ideas may—or may not—fit within an individual’s broader financial plan.

Your Take-Home

Evidence-based investing is not about accepting every newly discovered factor or investment idea. It is about applying a disciplined process for separating promising research from relationships that may prove temporary, impractical or unsupported.

As evidence continues to evolve, so should our understanding, but changes to an investment strategy should remain grounded in credible research, thoughtful implementation and individual circumstances.

In the next installment of this series, we will turn to a factor we have mentioned but have yet to explore in depth, even though it may be one of the most influential of all: you and your financial behaviors.

This post was written and first distributed by The Writing Company.

DISCLAIMERS

This material is intended for general public use. By providing this material, we are not undertaking to provide investment advice for any specific individual or situation, or to otherwise act in a fiduciary capacity. Please contact one of our financial professionals for guidance and information specific to your individual situation. This is not an offer to buy or sell a security.

Shore Point Advisors is an investment adviser located in Brielle, New Jersey. Shore Point Advisors is registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Registration of an investment adviser does not imply any specific level of skill or training and does not constitute an endorsement of the firm by the Commission. Shore Point Advisors only transacts business in states in which it is properly registered or is excluded or exempted from registration. Insurance products and services are offered through JCL Financial, LLC (“JCL”). Shore Point Advisors and JCL are affiliated entities.

SHARE THIS POST!

Facebook
LinkedIn
Email